Lesson 3 of 9 in the free Ethics and Moral Issues course.
A lecture on ethical relativism: what relativism claims, cases that seem obviously relative like food and fashion, cultural disagreement about practices, whether disagreement supports an epistemological conclusion, moral absolutism and what gives morality its authority, lying and moral reasoning, an analogy with discovering that water is H2O, subjectivism versus cultural relativism, and whether disagreement shows that moral theory itself is relative.
Chapters (1 hr 17 min)
0:00 Introduction
2:32 Things that seem obviously relative
5:01 Fashion and cultural differences
7:30 Relative terms: large and small
10:00 Why think morality is relative?
12:38 Cultural practices and moral disagreement
15:02 Past disagreement about the shape of the Earth
17:37 From disagreement to an epistemological conclusion
20:06 Truth and moral absolutism
22:32 Choosing between absolutism and relativism
25:06 What gives morality its authority?
27:31 Lying and a long-standing answer
30:01 Rationality and moral reasoning
32:34 Lying in The Terminator
35:07 An absolutism that accounts for circumstances
37:33 The relativist’s mistake
40:05 Taking a life to preserve your own
42:36 Discovering that water is H2O
45:00 Knowing all the properties
47:36 Fashion and preferences revisited
50:05 Is there reason to take relativism seriously?
52:33 Subjectivism
55:07 Divisions within cultures
57:33 Belonging to more than one culture
1:00:03 Do we really disagree?
1:02:35 Leaving children on the ice
1:05:00 Justification in context
1:07:30 Ordinary normative disagreement
1:10:00 Relativism at the level of moral theory
1:12:33 Defining relativism
1:15:00 Moral education
← Philosophical Ethics · All lessons · Socrates and the Socratic Turn →