Lesson 8 of 9 in the free Ethics and Moral Issues course.
Part 1: Utilitarianism I
I introduce utilitarianism through Jeremy Bentham’s original version: psychological and ethical hedonism, the greatest happiness principle, and the calculus for tallying pleasures and pains. I compare it with Kantian ethics on lying to the murderer at the door and test it with a lifeboat case and Bentham’s claim that push-pin is as good as poetry.
Chapters (16 min)
0:00 Introduction
1:00 Bentham’s hedonism
1:32 Psychological and ethical hedonism
3:00 The greatest happiness principle
4:02 Not a form of egoism
5:06 Measuring pleasure and pain
7:00 The hedonic calculus
8:32 Each to count for one
9:04 Animals count too
10:01 Utilitarianism versus Kant
12:07 The lifeboat case
14:31 Push-pin and poetry
Part 2: Utilitarianism II
I continue with utilitarianism: why counting animal suffering sets it apart from Kant, and John Stuart Mill’s revision of Bentham. Mill argues that intellectual pleasures are higher in quality than sensual ones, so it is better to be a human dissatisfied than a pig satisfied, and appeals to competent judges who have experienced both, much like wine tasters.
Chapters (17 min)
0:00 Introduction
0:35 Suffering, not reason
2:10 Mill and Bentham
2:40 Intellectual and sensual pleasures
4:18 A human dissatisfied or a pig satisfied
7:33 Answering Aristotle
9:07 Quality, not just quantity
10:46 How do we know which is better?
11:16 The wine taster
12:53 Competent judges
13:54 Philosophers on the higher pleasures
16:33 Conclusion
Part 3: Utilitarianism III
I use a thought experiment about killing a terminally ill neighbor and giving her money to charity to show where act utilitarianism seems to go wrong. I explain Mill’s unclear position, the distinction between act and rule utilitarianism, the case of a red light at 3 a.m., and a ticking-bomb case where the two views come apart.
Chapters (16 min)
0:00 Introduction
1:41 The terminally ill neighbor
4:16 Doing the calculation
5:21 Has something gone wrong?
6:25 Mill’s position
7:29 Act and rule utilitarianism
8:38 The rule against taking innocent life
10:11 Motivation and rules
12:21 The red light at 3 a.m.
13:58 A tension between the views
14:27 A ticking-bomb case
Part 4: Utilitarianism IV
A lecture on Peter Singer’s utilitarianism, equal consideration of interests and speciesism, and on John Rawls’ objection that utilitarianism can’t account for fairness, including the veil of ignorance and his principles of justice.
Chapters (26 min)
0:00 Introduction
0:16 Singer and equal consideration of interests
2:22 Speciesism
6:25 Pigs and humans
8:46 Strangers and those close to us
9:41 Utilitarianism and justice
10:04 Distributing happiness
11:41 Rawls on fairness
12:10 The veil of ignorance
15:02 Sacrificing an innocent person
16:05 Rawls’ principles of justice
20:02 Doctors and janitors
23:01 Inequalities that help the worst off
25:33 Combining earlier theories
← Kant’s Ethics · All lessons · Free Will and Moral Responsibility →