Katalin Balog Live!

Join me for a discussion with Katalin Balog, Professor of Philosophy at Rutgers University – Newark, as we discuss the metaphysics of consciousness and mind with a focus on Kati’s Dialectical Monism or the view that dualism and physicalism are somehow both correct, illusionism and the value of consciousness, and much more!

Kati’s website: https://hypatiaonhudson.net

New: Read the full transcript, find key moments, and cite this episode on its episode page.

In this episode

Katalin Balog on physicalism, phenomenal concepts and the first-person point of view: the phenomenal concept strategy, conceivability arguments, zombies and shombies, whether physicalism and dualism can both be true, AI consciousness, and her worry that illusionism, helped along by digital distraction, gives up on understanding ourselves from the inside.

Chapters
0:00 Introduction
3:34 Growing up in Hungary and coming to analytic philosophy
6:16 Phenomenal concepts and Brian Loar
10:20 Can consciousness be physical?
12:03 Why physicalism?
15:21 Deducing phenomenal facts from physical facts
18:11 Shombies
20:27 Is a physical duplicate without consciousness conceivable?
22:42 The phenomenal concept strategy
25:00 Negative conceivability
29:30 Explaining the puzzles of consciousness
32:53 Does the dispute fizzle?
34:36 Different concepts of property
37:30 Shombies vs. zombies
39:46 Could the world have lacked consciousness?
43:39 AI and biological consciousness
47:02 Substrate independence
49:51 Arguments against building conscious AI
55:35 Are physicalism and dualism both true?
59:58 Why the dispute is intractable
1:03:58 Illusionism and introspection
1:07:19 From Descartes to Ryle
1:10:45 Dispensing with the first person
1:15:48 Digital distraction and illusionism
1:21:27 Boredom and contemplation
1:24:10 Shombies, anti-zombies and illusionism
1:30:55 Science and what exists
1:33:40 Value without consciousness
1:36:28 Dehumanization and loss of connection
1:39:50 Wrap-up

★ Enjoying the show? Follow & rate Consciousness Live!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Latest from the blog

All posts [ -> ]